Capital Gains Tax Reliefto Bring More Homes to Market: What We Still Need to Know


There is a proposal that could bring more homes onto the housing market: exempting capital gains from personal income tax when someone sells a second property, provided the buyer turns it into their main residence. It sounds like a straightforward and targeted measure. But the tax benefit does not depend solely on the seller — it also depends on what the buyer does after completion. And that is precisely where the proposal becomes more complicated.
The Portuguese Socialist Party (PS) has proposed an exceptional scheme, lasting three years, which would exempt from personal income tax (IRS) capital gains arising from the sale of properties that are not the seller's main residence, provided they are located in designated urban pressure areas and become the buyer's main residence. The proposal provides for full tax relief on properties sold for up to €300,000 and a 50% reduction in the tax due on properties sold for between €300,000 and €500,000. It also includes exemption from Stamp Duty on the purchase and the associated mortgage.
On 6 November, following a meeting with the Prime Minister, the PS announced that the Government had expressed a willingness to consider these tax proposals. This signals a move towards agreement, but does not mean that a scheme has been approved. The precise conditions, monitoring arrangements and practical implementation still need to be established.
Portuguese law already provides for full or partial relief from capital gains tax in certain circumstances: selling one's main residence and reinvesting the proceeds in another home, reinvesting in residential rental property subject to the applicable conditions, the transitional tax treatment of properties acquired before 1989, and certain reinvestment options available to taxpayers aged 65 or over. This new proposal would be different: the tax benefit would depend on how the buyer uses the property after purchasing it.
Which homes would actually come onto the market?
The key question is who would change their decision because of the tax saving.
It may be owners with a substantial capital gain who are in no particular hurry to sell: the flat that has been empty for years, the inherited property that has yet to be dealt with, or the home whose future is still under consideration by the family. However, the incentive could also influence owners who were already considering selling and decide to bring the transaction forward to take advantage of the tax relief.
There is, though, a more fundamental question: how many owners are actually keeping properties off the market because of capital gains taxation?
A property may remain empty because the owner has no need to sell, expects its value to increase, faces disagreements between heirs, or because the property requires renovation. Taxation may be one of the reasons, but we do not know whether it is the main one.
There is another possible effect to consider. An owner who currently lets a property may start considering a sale if the tax advantage makes that option more attractive. The measure could therefore increase the supply of properties for sale while simultaneously reducing the number available to rent.
It also remains to be clarified whether an owner selling two properties that meet the scheme's criteria could benefit from the exemption on both. Would the €300,000 threshold apply separately to each property, or would there be a limit per taxpayer? And how would the benefit be calculated where a property has several co-owners?
The incentive may work, but it is important to understand which properties it will actually affect and who will be able to benefit.
What about prices?
Will the tax saving reach the buyer?
Where several people are interested in the same property, the seller has little reason to accept less than the market is prepared to pay. Where there is no interest, the tax saving does not guarantee that a sale will take place either.
The benefit could reach households indirectly if more properties coming onto the market help moderate prices. But that depends on the number of properties made available, their location and the balance between supply and demand.
Based on what I see on property portals in the Oeste region, I am concerned that some of the properties brought to market under this measure may be priced close to or above €300,000.
In a recent Casa Gold article, "With Two Median Salaries, What Home Can a Family Afford in Lisbon, Porto and the Oeste Region?", we examined the purchasing capacity of a household with two median salaries. In that analysis, we used a mortgage of €203,000 as a reference point when assessing access to home ownership.
How many properties covered by this measure would actually be within reach of a household with that level of borrowing capacity?
The reduced-taxation band between €300,000 and €500,000 widens the range of properties potentially covered, but it does not resolve the affordability issue. A property may qualify for a tax advantage for the seller and still remain beyond the reach of a significant proportion of households looking for a home.
Where is the boundary?
It makes sense to target the incentive at areas where finding a home is more difficult. However, urban pressure areas are designated by local authorities, while housing markets do not always follow administrative boundaries.
Imagine two similar houses in the Oeste region, just a few minutes apart, both sold for €250,000 to families who intend to live there. If only one is located within a designated urban pressure area, only its seller will qualify for the tax exemption.
A family working in the region may look for a home across several parishes and neighbouring municipalities. If prices, demand and shortages are similar on both sides of an administrative boundary, what justifies the difference in tax treatment?
Geographical boundaries may be necessary to target the incentive, but they can also create unequal treatment for owners and buyers in property markets that, in practice, operate as a single region.
What about properties that need renovation?
The proposal aims to bring existing homes into use, but not all properties are ready for new occupants.
Consider a flat sold for €280,000 that needs €50,000 or €60,000 of work before it becomes habitable. The buyer must be able to finance not only the purchase but also the renovation.
How much time will the buyer have to complete the work and establish the property as their main residence? Will the tax condition start from completion, or only once the property is fit for occupation?
If the intention is to bring more homes onto the market, those requiring work before they can fulfil their intended purpose should not be overlooked.
What will be required of the buyer?
If the proposal goes ahead, the law will need to clarify how long buyers have to move in, how they must demonstrate that they live there, and whether they will be required to remain for a minimum period.
Consider a family that buys a property, changes its registered tax address and, a few months later, one of its members is transferred to another city for work. The family then decides to let the property. If the new tenants use it as their main residence, what happens to the tax exemption granted to the seller?
A change of circumstances due to work, supported by appropriate evidence, should be treated as an exceptional case. It should also be made clear whether subsequently letting the property as a permanent home allows the tax benefit to remain in place.
There is another essential question: who is liable if the buyer fails to meet the property's occupancy requirements? Will the seller have to repay tax that they were exempted from because of a decision they can no longer control?
Sellers should be able to calculate the financial implications before completion, with the assurance that the tax benefit will not be jeopardised by decisions made by the buyer afterwards. Liability for non-compliance must be clearly defined, as must the monitoring arrangements.
And what if the parties deliberately cooperate to avoid paying tax? How would this be detected? Who would be responsible for monitoring compliance, and what resources would be available?
What should be measured at the end?
Three years later, we will need more than just the number of transactions that benefited from the exemption. We will need to know how many homes actually came onto the market because of it, the prices at which they were sold, where they were located and how many continued to be used as main residences.
It will also be important to understand how many of these properties required renovation, how many came from the rental market, and whether the incentive succeeded in bringing onto the market homes that would otherwise have remained unavailable.
There is another effect worth distinguishing: how many sales took place because the measure changed the owners' decisions, and how many were simply brought forward to take advantage of the tax relief? A temporary three-year measure may encourage some owners to sell earlier, without necessarily creating a lasting increase in housing supply.
There is a difference between giving tax relief to people who already intended to sell and persuading those who would not otherwise have done so.
That distinction will determine whether the measure has been successful.
The proposal starts from an understandable intention: to make better use of existing homes and improve access to housing. But between a tax advantage and a home actually becoming available to a family, there are several decisions, conditions and obstacles along the way.
Without clear rules, appropriate monitoring and public data to assess the results, this measure risks becoming a tax saving for some property owners without delivering the increase in housing supply it is intended to achieve.
